Unveiling the Superiority of Traditional Electric Dog Fences Over GPS: A Comparative Exploration

GPS Fence shocking dog

Traditional electric dog fences reign supreme in pet containment, while GPS systems remain untested and unreliable. Physical fences pose numerous challenges—HOA restrictions, high costs, and aesthetic drawbacks—making them a poor choice. GPS fences, reliant on signals, are prone to glitches and accuracy issues, risking pets’ safety. Conversely, traditional fences with buried wires offer consistent, weather-resistant containment, ensuring immediate responses at boundaries. Opting for traditional electric dog fences guarantees superior pet safety over untested GPS alternatives, eliminating the pitfalls of physical fences.

Don't buy GPS Fences

Negatives of GPS Location Dog Fence Systems:

Unreliability

Inaccuracy and Unreliability:

GPS signals affected by atmospheric conditions, buildings, and foliage, leading to erratic boundary lines. Inconsistency causing confusion and potential danger for pets.

Signal Delays

Signal Delays:

Delay in updating the dog’s location compared to instant physical barriers. Critical situations might suffer due to delayed signals, risking the pet’s safety.

Limited Customization

Limited Customization:

Difficulty in creating custom boundaries for irregularly shaped or small yards. Leaves areas unprotected or restricts the pet’s movement unnecessarily.

Short Battery Life

Battery Life and Maintenance:

Reliance on rechargeable batteries with limited lifespan. Risks leaving the pet vulnerable if the battery runs out while outside the designated area, requiring regular maintenance for functionality.

Risk of Overstimulation

Risk of Overstimulation:

Utilization of static correction methods may lead to pet anxiety or fear. Potential behavioral issues impacting the pet’s overall well-being.

High Cost

High Initial Cost:

Higher upfront expenses including collar purchase, base station, and potential subscription fees. Less accessible option compared to traditional fences due to cost.

Positives of Traditional Wired Systems:

Reliability

Reliability:

Guarantees a dependable and consistent boundary without dependence on signals influenced by environmental factors.

Instant Barrier

Instant Barrier:

Provides an immediate physical boundary, preventing any delays in safeguarding the pet.

Customization

Customization

Tailorable to fit the specific layout of a yard, accommodating irregular shapes or sizes effectively.

No Battery Dependency

No Battery Dependency

No reliance on batteries, eliminating the risk of the pet wandering due to battery failure.

No Overstimulation Risk

No Overstimulation Risk

Lacks electronic correction methods, reducing the risk of causing anxiety or fear in pets.

Potentially Lower Initial Cost

Potentially Lower Initial Cost

Usually, traditional fences have lower initial costs without additional subscription fees or technology expenses.

Conclusion:

While the concept of GPS location dog fence systems is enticing, the practical implementation reveals a host of issues that can compromise the safety and well-being of our beloved pets. As technology advances, it is crucial for manufacturers to address these drawbacks and work towards creating more reliable and effective solutions. Until then, pet owners should carefully weigh the pros and cons before investing in a GPS dog fence system, considering the unique needs and behaviors of their furry companions.

Side-by-Side Analysis Chart:

This comparison highlights the drawbacks of GPS location dog fence systems against the advantages of traditional wired systems, offering a clearer understanding of the trade-offs between the two options for pet owners.

WIEZ® GPS Wireless Dog Fence Halo® Brand GPS SpotOn® GPS Brand PetSafe® Brand GPS Traditional Wired Fence Extreme® Brand
Inaccuracy and Unreliability Inaccuracy and Unreliability Inaccuracy and Unreliability Inaccuracy and Unreliability Reliability
Signal Delays Signal Delays Signal Delays Signal Delays Instant Barrier
Limited Customization Limited Customization Limited Customization Limited Customization Customization
Battery Life and Maintenance Battery Life and Maintenance Battery Life and Maintenance Battery Life and Maintenance No Battery Dependency
Risk of Overstimulation Risk of Overstimulation Risk of Overstimulation Risk of Overstimulation No Overstimulation Risk
High Initial Cost High Initial Cost High Initial Cost High Initial Cost Potentially Lower Initial Cost
See Amazon Reviews See Amazon Reviews See Amazon Reviews See Amazon Reviews See Amazon Reviews
$129 on Amazon $699 on Amazon $1295 on Amazon $599 on Amazon $299 on Amazon

Amazon GPS Reviews

1-star Unreliable

By Angelo Farrow on 10/17/2023

The biggest issue is boundary and emergency warnings going off when the dog is just sitting and chewing a bone…

Angelo’s full comment
1-star Waste of Money!

By theGulaFamily on 09/27/2023

REceived my second unit worked for a month, and died as well. 3rd (replacement) unit just stopped working as well – …

TheGulaFamily’s full comment
1-star Trees are bad…

By DT Harvell on 09/23/2023

Item did not perform to expectation. If you have wooded property, the Guardian doesn’t work. Also the refund can take up to thirty days?…

DT’s full comment
1-star SpottyOn…

By billy brown on 07/25/2023

The signal is hit or miss even with good by service. Plus, if you buy the collar from Amazon, SpotOn will not stand by their product…

Billy’s full comment