Product Reviews

Why trust us?

eXtreme Dog Fence invests its time and energy researching, analyzing and testing products in order to recommend the best choices for most consumers. All products are bought with our own funds, never accepting freebies from manufacturers.  
Bottom Line



Double Flap Performance Aluminum Dog Door

Manufactured from only the highest quality of aluminum

Its strong magnets and double flaps ensure supreme weatherproofing


Endura Pet 

Double Flap Wall Mount Pet Door

Designed to combat 50 MPH winds and -40 degree temperatures


Features a secure locking cover

Comes at a high price point

Ideal Pet Products

Ruff Weather Pet Door for Doors

Good for those on a limited budget

A reasonable price

Plastic flaps and frame


Freedom Aluminum Patio Panel Sliding Glass Pet Door

The aluminum frame is designed to fit within a sliding glass door.

Great for apartments or condos because you can take it with you wherever you go.

Not well-insulated


Extreme Weather Energy-Efficient Pet Door

Has 3 flaps for weather resistance and can be installed in doors or walls.

Low price point and a paintable plastic frame.

Has plastic flaps and frame.

How we decided

Every product we review is purchased with our own funds. No freebies are ever accepted from product manufacturers.

  • 84 Models Considered
  • 10 Hours Researched
  • 1 Experts Interviewed
  • 94 Consumers Consulted



Shopping guide for best dog doors

Last Updated January 2019

Consider the Size

Before purchasing a dog door, consider what breed your pooch is. A dog’s size is a factor, which depends on the breed.

Avoid purchasing a small dog door just because you have a puppy. Remember that your puppy won’t be small forever, and will outgrow the door. For this reason, your pet door should have an opening that will fit the dog once they have matured.

In order for you to determine the size of dog door to buy, measuring your dog is necessary. There are 4 measurements for you to take.

Height is the first. Measure from the dog’s paws to the lower part of the chest to the highest part of the shoulders. Allow 2” at the top of the shoulders.

Measure the width of one shoulder blade to the other, giving a 2 inch allowance.

The weight of the dog is also a factor. Buy a dog door whose weight correlates with the recommended weight of the door.

Make sure that the pet door is going accommodates the thickness of your door or wall.

Safety and Security

While it is important to buy an energy-efficient dog door, you shouldn’t overlook the level of security that the door offers. Consider the door’s locking system. Some pet doors have metal locking covers, while others do not.

Quality Materials

To make sure that the door is going to last, be sure to buy a dog door that is made of tough and premium quality-materials that are resistant to corrosion and weather. The flaps should be flexible but safe.

Door Flaps or Cover

Your dog door’s flaps should be sturdy enough to withstand strong gusts of wind. Going with a door that has double flaps will provide extra insulation from harsh weather conditions.

Structure of the Frame

Is the frame made of plastic or aluminum? Will it be sufficient to prevent heat losses, and is it strong enough to deter chewing from your dog?